The Santas of Cold Spring

By Chip Rowe

Santa has heard it all.

“Were you born on Christmas?”

“Is your last name Claus?”

“Is that really your name?”

A lifelong Cold Spring resident, Santa Warren usually smiles and explains that her full name is Santa Maria, that she was named after her Italian-American mother (although her mother had no middle name), and that she was born on the relatively uneventful date of January 29.

Santa Warren with her mother, Santa Huston
Santa Warren with her mother, Santa Huston

“My mother was 5 feet tall, and I am 5’3”, but she was always Big Santa and I was Little Santa,” says Warren, who is familiar to many residents of Philipstown because of her volunteer work for local youth soccer, the Haldane PTA and Our Lady of Loretto.

Warren, 43, who doesn’t have siblings, says it was tough having the name as a child because of the teasing from classmates – she didn’t name either of her daughters Santa (Sarah, 17, Sydney, 10, and Seth, 14, all attend Haldane). But as an adult she loves being called Santa, even with its unique burden – everybody remembers her name even when she can’t remember theirs.

She says a few people over the years have told her they know someone else named Santa, “but more often they think they misheard me, and they repeat it back as Sandra. If I don’t think I’ll ever see them again, rather than explain, I just go with Sandra.”

Santa is not the only Santa in town. At one time there were three – Warren, her mother, Santa (Frisenda) Huston, who died in 2007, and her mother’s cousin, Santa Maria (Frisenda) Ferrara, 91, also a lifelong Cold Spring resident. Both cousins were named for their paternal grandmother in Italy, Santa (Castrovinci) Frisenda.

Ferrara, who grew up in Cold Spring in the 1920s and 1930s, says she didn’t get much grief about her name, in part because her parents were immigrants. “We didn’t have too many friends” outside of the local Italian community, she said.

The Warren family
The Warren family

Santa translates as “saint” or “holy” in Italian or Spanish. (“I’m a saint!” Ferrara claimed, although, when pressed, she quickly added with a laugh: “Are you kidding?”). Santa was a more common name in the U.S. a century ago. Between 1904 and 1931, it ranked among the top 1,000 for newborn girls. (Ferrara was born in 1922, and Huston in 1929.) In 1990, the most recent census data available, more than 1,200 women had the name, making it the 1,224th most popular, between Dominga and Melodie.

The male equivalent is Santo, although Warren says she gets plenty of junk mail for Mr. Santa Warren. The male Santa familiar to Americans is thought to originate with the Dutch tradition of Sinter Klaas. The name appeared in print in the U.S. as early as 1821, in an obscure poem that begins, “Old Santeclaus with much delight … ”

Warren jokes she could have married someone named Claus instead of her high-school sweetheart, Scott Warren. And Santa Santa was also a possibility, as more than 2,000 people in the U.S. have that surname and surely have grown weary of the Christmas Eve phone calls.

Photos courtesy Santa Warren

One Response to "The Santas of Cold Spring"

  1. Maria Cofini   December 27, 2013 at 4:09 pm

    I have to admit, I asked twice what her name was to a friend, not her directly. Ever since that I have known Santa as a wonderful person to be friends with. She is always positive and pleasant and helps in any way she can wherever we are. Her husband and children are equally as nice. And, on top of all that I love her name!