Roots and Shoots: Deer Resistant? Well, Maybe

By Pamela Doan

After trying to grow flowers and vegetables for years in a yard that’s surrounded by forest, I have learned a lot about the appetites of deer.

In Putnam County, there are as many as 100 deer per square mile in some places; the average is 40 to 60. Compare that to upstate areas where there are six to 10 deer per square mile and you can see the problem. As land has become more residential, there aren’t wolves or mountain lions to prey on the deer and their numbers keep increasing.

Like many forests, mine is barren of plants and tree seedlings except for the invasive plants deer won’t eat. Unless I put up a fence, that situation won’t change. The ecosystem has shifted and habitat for other wildlife, insects and birds is lost, as well. I could fill this entire column with environmental and health issues but the point here is, what can you plant in these conditions?

Where I live, pretty much everything in the yard has been nibbled except for the awful Japanese barberry and the forsythia. I’ve learned that “deer resistance” is relative to how hungry the deer are. “All bets are off when they’re starving,” says Jennifer Stengle, an educator with the Cornell Cooperative Extension Resource of Putnam County.

A whitetail buck browsing in the woods in springtime (Photo by Bruce Macqueen)

At a forum on March 26 hosted by the Hudson Highlands Land Trust, Stengle explained that deer are “adaptive generalists,” which means they can live almost anywhere and are not picky about their diet and shelter.

Plants that deer tend to leave alone have milky sap like milkweeds, hairy leaves like lamb’s ears and fragrant leaves like mints and lavender.

Some plants, shrubs and trees can withstand deer browsing better than others. Joe Pye weed, false indigo and bluestar are resilient and can recover. Two kinds of spirea — meadowsweet and steeple bush or hardhack — are generally left alone. Stengle recommends fragrant sumac and shrubby cinquefoil.

Elderberries are a good example of a plant that evolved to protect itself from hungry wildlife. All parts of it are poisonous — the leaves, bark and buds — but when it produces fruit, the berries can be eaten. This strategy lets it produce new bushes because animals spread the seeds in their feces.

Deer have been found to browse pretty much all native evergreens and dogwoods, so these “need to be protected until they can get established” and become deer resistant, Stengle says.

Bluestar will tolerate some deer browsing but is usually not bothered. (Wildflower.org)

All of these recommendations add value to the landscape beyond being deer tolerant. They feed pollinators or attract insects for birds or make shelter for other wildlife. We tend to rely on the same daffodils, forsythia and grasses that don’t have those qualities. By adding diversity and native plants, it’s possible to create a sustainable habitat that’s more than a pretty flowerbed.

I’ve heard of planting techniques to discourage deer that include surrounding deer favorites with deer-resistant plants. But Stengle says that doesn’t work. “The deer go right through to the plant they want,” she says.

The only defenses that research has shown to be effective are barriers and spray repellents based on putrescent egg solids known as “the stinky ones.” Stengle cautions against using herbal oil-based sprays because they can harm pollinators. “Oils don’t dry and they form a film over the insect,” she says. “If you spray plants that are blooming, you can kill the pollinators.” The stinky sprays haven’t been shown to do harm.

Want to grow vegetables? Spraying your tomatoes and lettuce with putrescent egg solids doesn’t improve the flavor, so you’ll need a fence. It needs to be about 6 feet high and buried 6 to 12 inches to keep out the woodchucks, rabbits and raccoons.

2 Responses to "Roots and Shoots: Deer Resistant? Well, Maybe"

  1. Stephen Rose   April 5, 2017 at 5:23 pm

    Ferns! They make a beautiful deerproof woodland, although no flowers. Blackberry lily and monarda add deerproof color.

    Reply
  2. Sue Travis   April 13, 2017 at 6:49 am

    Deer are afraid of egg shells, so leave some shells around the garden. You do need to check and make sure other animals haven’t taken the shells. This really does help.

    Reply

What Do You Think?

To keep the discourse at its highest level, we have a few rules: (1) Posts must have the full name of poster (no first name only, no pseudonyms) and a valid email address. (2) All comments are reviewed by a moderator before they are posted. (3) A civil tone is important. Attack the argument, not the person. (4) Posts will be edited for spelling and grammar. All comments may also appear in print.

Your email address will not be published.