Walking into the Past

Library director will lead Cold Spring history tour

By Alison Rooney

When Gillian Thorpe was appointed 18 years ago as director of the Julia L. Butterfield Library, she says it seemed like the culmination of her decades-long obsession with the wealthy Cold Spring woman who in 1913 provided the funds to build and stock the structure.

Julia L. Butterfield

When Thorpe was a child growing up in Cold Spring, “Mrs. Rathjen, who gave us kids cookies from her porch on Mountain Avenue, told us of seeing Julia Butterfield going by in her carriage.” When Julia Butterfield’s summer home, Cragside, burned down in 1979 on the site of what is now Haldane High School, Thorpe remembers standing in a nightgown, watching.

“I’ve been a bit obsessed with Mrs. Butterfield since I was a child,” admits Thorpe. “She is forgotten among our local history. Whenever students visit our library, I tell them about her.”

Butterfield and her realm will be the focus of a tour that Thorpe will lead on Saturday, June 23, in what she hopes will be the first of monthly walks on various historical themes. Digital, self-guided audio versions will be posted online.

The tour will begin at 9 a.m. at the library, then head up Craigside Drive (Thorpe will explain the change in spelling) to the site of the former home, with several stops on the Haldane campus, including the Mabel Merritt administrative building, once the property’s stables.

Gillian Thorpe outside the former Butterfield carriage house, now a private residence (Photo by A. Rooney)

From there the group will advance to James Pond, which Thorpe describes as the Butterfield watering hole; to Cold Spring Cemetery, which holds the family tombs; and to the site of Butterfield Hospital, now redeveloped but with a prominent street named Julia Lane.

Born in 1823, at age 18 Julia Lorillard Safford married Frederick James, a broker and banker in New York City. They lived on Fifth Avenue and in 1852 in Cold Spring built a magnificent stone village house that was named Cragside because it had been constructed on a hillside strewn with rocks. It was surrounded by elaborate gardens, lawns, orchards and fields, according to Trudie Grace, author of Around Cold Spring.

Where the Money Went

Bequests by Julia Butterfield in her 1913 will, with current values

YMCA – $2.32 million ($59m)
Julia L. Butterfield Memorial Hospital – $150K ($3.8m)
Union College, Schenectady – $100K ($2.5m)
Julia L. Butterfield Memorial Library – $60K ($1.5m)
Home for the Relief of Respectable Aged Indigent Females – $20K ($500K)
Association for the Aid of Crippled Children – $10K ($250K)
St. Mary’s Episcopal Church (for parsonage) – $10K ($250K)
Association of New York Day Nurseries – $5K ($125K)

A gatehouse built in 1866 still stands at the foot of Craigside Drive as a private residence. An expansive terrace still remains, as well, although “you have to peer into the woods to see it,” says Thorpe.

Frederick James died in 1884. Two years later, Julia married Daniel Butterfield, a Civil War general who is credited with composing “Taps” and whose father co-founded American Express. He lived until 1901. When Julia died in 1913, her estate estimated to be worth $3 million, or about $75 million today.

Butterfield Memorial Hospital was built in 1925 and torn down in 2015.

Although most of her wealth was left to the Young Men’s Christian Association, Butterfield bequeathed $150,000 for the construction of a hospital and $60,000 for a public library to be located in the village and include a stage.

Haldane High School now occupies the site of Cragside.

The Georgian Revival building was constructed on the foundation of the old Dutch Reformed Church and dedicated in 1925. The hospital, finished the same year, was built, many believed, because one of Julia’s sons had died after a fall from a horse and she felt he might have survived if a hospital had been closer.

To reserve a spot on the tour, visit butterfieldlibrary.org and click on Calendar. For the online maps, click on History Tours.

Did you find this article useful or informative? Please consider a donation to support our work. Even $5 a month would be terrific. We are able to provide this website and our weekly print paper free to the community because of readers like you.

One Response to "Walking into the Past"

  1. Charles Ralston   June 20, 2018 at 10:16 am

    Alison Rooney’s “Walking into the Past” for this reader was akin to Proust’s epiphanic “tea and madeleine” moment.

    Flashback to November 1978, when my wife and I had our firstborn, Bridget, delivered that Saturday morning at the Julia L. Butterfield Memorial Hospital. The evening before I had completed another workday on a project of converting from Dewey Decimal to the Library of Congress classification of books in the Cadet Library at West Point and was taking a “break” at Eamon Fallon’s Southgate Tavern, just outside the Thayer Gate. My wife Michele called the Southgate (she knew I would be there) and the bartender, Paul, told me I had to go home, something about water breaking.

    I went immediately home and loaded my wife and all kinds of “grab and go — we’re having a baby” gear. I drove carefully but hurriedly through Highland Falls and Fort Montgomery, around the traffic circle to the Bear Mountain Bridge, and on to Route 9D to Butterfield Hospital. Bridget, a Veterans’ Day baby, will celebrate her 40th later this year.

    Last week (June 11 to 17), I was again at West Point, celebrating with my fellow veterans the 50th anniversary of the deployment to the Republic of Vietnam of the 3rd Brigade of the 82nd Airborne Division, which served there from February 1968 to December 1969. It was my first time getting back together with veterans from the 82nd. And, although I was at the Academy for a gathering of fellow Army librarians two decades ago, this was the first time back in Highland Falls since August 1987 when I moved to metro Atlanta to take a library position at the headquarters of the U.S. Army Forces Command.

    I found it interesting that Butterfield Hospital tried merging with Vassar Brothers in Poughkeepsie. Our second daughter, Alexandra, was born at Butterfield in 1981, and our third, Caitlin, at Vassar Brothers in 1987, where her mother was born in 1953. Unwittingly, I can say that I did my part to help with the merger of these two hospitals.

    Walking into the past is to enter the labyrinth of history.

    Reply

What Do You Think?

The Current welcomes comments on its coverage and local issues. Submissions are selected by the editor to provide a variety of opinions and voices, and all are subject to editing for accuracy, clarity and length. We ask that writers remain civil and avoid personal attacks. Submissions must include your first and last name (no pseudonyms), as well as a valid email address. Please allow up to 24 hours for an approved submission to be posted. All online comments may also appear in print.

Your email address will not be published.